Quick verdict: The Elderberry Co. is a real, family-owned business based in New Albany, Indiana. It sells a small-batch elderberry syrup sweetened with raw honey. The syrup is priced close to Sambucol per ounce. It's a reasonable buy if you like a fresh, refrigerated syrup and will finish the jar within about 60 days. Skip it if you're buying for a baby under 12 months, you need a vegan product, or you want lab results you can actually read. Know two things before you order: the syrup can't be returned, and the brand received an FDA warning letter in 2020 over health claims.

The Elderberry Co at a glance

 

 

Founded

November 2017, New Albany, Indiana (founder Jenny Watson)

Best-known product

Elderberry Syrup in 8, 16 and 32 oz jars

Price (8 oz)

$21.99 one-time · $19.79 with Subscribe & Save (10% off)

Syrup ingredients

Water, organic elderberries, organic aronia berries, raw local honey, ginger, Ceylon cinnamon, clove

Shipping

U.S. only, no PO boxes, ships in 1–4 business days

Returns

15 days for unused items. Elderberry Syrup is excluded.

Independent reviews

Few: about 11 Yelp reviews averaging 5.0

Regulatory history

FDA warning letter dated 9/8/2020

What we like

  • Short ingredient list: berries, honey and spices, with no preservatives.
  • Price per ounce is close to Sambucol and cheaper than most kids' elderberry brands.
  • A clean county food inspection: the 3/5/2025 inspection found no violations.
  • Flexible subscriptions: delivery every 1 to 12 weeks, cancel anytime.

What gives us pause

  • The syrup is non-returnable, and the guarantee wording conflicts between pages.
  • A "3rd Party Tested" badge with no lab name or COA on the product pages we checked.
  • A "Vegan" badge on a syrup made with raw honey.
  • Few independent reviews compared with the brand's own "5,000+ reviews" claim.

How we researched this review

We did not buy, taste or test The Elderberry Co.'s products. This is a research report. Its job is to read everything so you don't have to.

On 11/11/2026 we:

  1. Read The Elderberry Co.'s product pages, FAQ, refund policy and shipping policy.
  2. Searched the FDA warning-letter database and county health inspection records.
  3. Looked for independent customer reviews on Yelp, Trustpilot and other review platforms.
  4. Compared per-ounce prices with Sambucol and Gaia Herbs at major U.S. retailers.

Data limits: We found only about 11 independent reviews, all on Yelp. That's too few to report a satisfaction rate, so we don't. On the product pages we checked, The Elderberry Co.'s review widgets were empty, so we couldn't analyze its own "5,000+ reviews" either. More on our process: how we research and rate stores.

Is The Elderberry Co legit?

Yes. The Elderberry Co. is a legitimate, registered business with a real storefront at 302 Pearl St., Suite B, in New Albany, Indiana. Founder Jenny Watson started selling homemade syrup in 2017. In a February 2025 BizVoice profile, she reported about 15 employees and sales of $3.2 million in 2020. The Floyd County Health Department inspected the shop on 3/5/2025 and recorded no violations.

Being legitimate doesn't mean every claim is supported, though. That's the next section.

Watch out for look-alike names. If you search for reviews, you'll find two similarly named companies:

  • The Elderberry Source has a 4.8-star Trustpilot page, but it's a separate Las Vegas business. Its reviews tell you nothing about The Elderberry Co.
  • The Elderberry Fairy & Co. received its own FDA warning letter in 2022. That letter has nothing to do with The Elderberry Co.

The 2020 FDA warning letter: what it said and why it matters

On 9/8/2020, the FDA sent The Elderberry Co. a warning letter about how it marketed its Elderberry Syrup and Elderberry Syrup Kit. The letter quoted the homepage's "Fights Colds, Flus and Allergies" line. It also cited FAQ, blog and Facebook posts that called elderberries anti-viral and anti-inflammatory.

The FDA said those claims made the products unapproved new drugs. It also said they were misbranded, because colds and flu can't be safely self-treated based on a label. The company was asked to correct the claims within 15 working days.

What this means for you:

  • It isn't a recall or a safety finding. The letter is about marketing claims, not contamination.
  • The FDA page shows no close-out letter. A close-out letter would confirm that the issues were resolved.
  • Similar wording is still on the site. On our 11/11/2026 visit, the homepage still said elderberries help shorten colds, flu and allergies. [VERIFY: add a dated screenshot]

The Elderberry Co. wasn't singled out. In 2020, the FDA and FTC sent warning letters to many herbal sellers over cold, flu and COVID-19 claims. Still, keep the letter in mind when you read health claims on any elderberry site.

What does the science say about elderberry?

The NIH's National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) summarizes the research this way:

  • Colds and flu: A few small, preliminary studies suggest elderberry may ease symptoms of upper respiratory infections. The evidence is limited.
  • COVID-19: There's no good evidence that elderberry helps.
  • Raw berries are toxic: Raw or unripe elderberries, leaves and stems can cause nausea, vomiting and severe diarrhea. Cooking destroys the toxin. This matters if you buy The Elderberry Co.'s dried berries or DIY syrup kit: cook them fully.
  • Pregnancy and breastfeeding: Little is known about safety. The Elderberry Co.'s own FAQ tells you to ask a physician.
  • Medications: If you take any medicine, check with your clinician before using elderberry.

Dietary supplements don't need FDA approval before they're sold, so the seller is responsible for their safety and labels. This section is general information, not medical advice.

Elderberry Syrup review: ingredients, freshness and storage

The Elderberry Co.'s Elderberry Syrup is a cooked syrup of elderberries and aronia berries, sweetened with raw local honey and spiced with ginger, Ceylon cinnamon and clove. The brand lists about 800 mg of elderberry and 4 g of carbohydrates per tablespoon.

This syrup isn't shelf-stable, so it needs more care than drugstore brands:

  • It ships without ice. The brand says it's designed to travel unrefrigerated.
  • Refrigerate it as soon as it arrives, even before opening.
  • Use it within about 60 days of the batch date printed on the jar.
  • To keep it longer, freeze it. The brand suggests ice-cube trays, which keep for 6 to 8 months.

Watch the labels. The product page shows a "Vegan" badge, but raw honey isn't vegan. It also shows a "3rd Party Tested" badge with no lab name and no Certificate of Analysis (COA). If verified potency matters to you, email the company for a COA before you buy. [UPDATE if a COA is published]

Taste: The few public reviews we found mostly praise the flavor and describe it as sweet and berry-forward. That's too small a sample to promise you'll like it.

How long does a jar of The Elderberry Co syrup last?

This is the question most people skip, and it decides which size you should buy. Each jar has to be used within about 60 days of its batch date. Here is how long each size lasts at the brand's suggested daily amounts: 1 tablespoon for adults and 1 teaspoon for children 12 months and older.

Household (daily use)

8 oz jar

16 oz jar

32 oz jar

1 adult (1 tbsp/day)

16 days

32 days

64 days ⚠️

1 child (1 tsp/day)

48 days

96 days ⚠️

192 days ⚠️

2 adults + 2 kids

6 days

12 days

24 days

⚠️ = runs past the brand's ~60-day best-by window unless you freeze part of it. Math: 1 fl oz = 2 tbsp = 6 tsp.

Our sizing rules:

  • Single adult: the 16 oz jar is the largest that's safe to buy without freezing.
  • One child: stick with 8 oz, which already lasts about seven weeks.
  • A family of four: buy 32 oz on a 2- to 3-week subscription. Smaller jars run out within a week.

Price check: The Elderberry Co vs drugstore brands

Product

Size

Price

Per fl oz

The Elderberry Co. Syrup (one-time)

8 oz

$21.99

$2.75

The Elderberry Co. Syrup (subscription)

8 oz

$19.79

$2.47

Sambucol Original Syrup at ShopRite

7.8 oz

$21.99

$2.82

Sambucol Original Syrup at CVS

7.8 oz

$24.99

$3.20

Gaia Herbs GaiaKids Black Elderberry Syrup at Walmart

3 oz

$19.79

$6.60

Prices seen on retailer pages during our 11/2026 research and subject to change. [RE-CHECK all prices on publish day] 16 oz and 32 oz Elderberry Co. prices: [CONFIRM AT CHECKOUT]. The site shows a $31.48 reference price without naming the size.

The caveat: per ounce isn't the same as per dose. Sambucol lists 3.8 g of elderberry juice concentrate per 2 teaspoons. The Elderberry Co. lists 800 mg of elderberry per tablespoon. Those measure different things, so you can't compare potency from the labels alone. Sambucol is shelf-stable and you can return it to most retailers. The Elderberry Co. syrup is fresher, contains no preservatives, and can't be returned.

Planning a bigger order? Our price analyzer tool can help you judge whether a "sale" price is really a deal.

Elderberry Immunity Gummies vs syrup: which is the better value?

The Elderberry Immunity Gummies come in 60- and 90-count bottles. The 60-count is $47.99, or $43.19 with Subscribe & Save. They're made with pectin rather than gelatin, and the label lists no honey.

  • Cost per adult day: Gummies cost about $1.60/day at 2 gummies a day. The syrup costs about $1.37/day at 1 tablespoon.
  • What's missing: the gummy page doesn't state how much elderberry is in each serving, or the sugar per serving. Organic cane sugar and tapioca syrup are near the top of the ingredient list.
  • Who they suit: people who can't keep a refrigerated jar on hand, or who dislike syrup. For children, the brand itself says to check with a pediatrician first.

The Elderberry Co coupons and ways to save (as of 11/11/2026)

We found these offers on theelderberryco.com on 11/11/2026. We didn't complete a test checkout, so confirm the final price in your cart. [VERIFY each offer on publish day]

Offer

How it works

Works on subscriptions?

Subscribe & Save

10% off every delivery

Yes

"Treat Yourself" tiers (no code)

$5 off $50 · $10 off $75 · $20 off $100 · $30 off $130

No

MOMSROCK

$15 off orders over $75

Yes

FourthShip

Free standard shipping

[CONFIRM]

Free soap bar

Free Cranberry Orange Bar Soap on orders over $50

[CONFIRM]

Which deal wins?

  • One-time orders of $100 or more: the automatic $20 tier beats MOMSROCK's $15.
  • One-time orders of $130 or more: the $30 tier takes about 23% off, the best deal on the site.
  • Subscriptions: MOMSROCK is the only listed code that works, on top of the 10% subscription discount.
  • Stacking: we don't know yet whether codes stack with the tiers. [CONFIRM AT CHECKOUT]

For current codes, see our [INTERNAL LINK: The Elderberry Co coupon page — verify slug in sitemap].

Shipping and returns: read this before you order

Shipping: Orders ship within 1–4 business days, U.S. only, and not to PO boxes. Some third-party listings say the brand ships to Canada, but its shipping policy says it doesn't.

Free shipping terms don't match across the site:

  • The product page: free shipping on one-time orders over $50 and subscriptions over $25.
  • The shipping policy: lists no free-shipping threshold at all.
  • The homepage: offers the FourthShip code for free standard shipping.

Check your cart total before you pay.

Returns: Unused items in their original packaging can be returned within 15 days. Elderberry Syrup is excluded. The policy offers a "100% Customer Satisfaction Guarantee" for the syrup instead, but doesn't say what it covers. The product page separately advertises a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Our tip: if a jar arrives damaged or tastes off, email info@theelderberryco.com right away with photos and the batch date. Take a screenshot of the guarantee wording when you order.

Who should buy The Elderberry Co, and who should skip it

Buy The Elderberry Co. if you:

  • Want a simple, honey-sweetened syrup with no preservatives and have room in the fridge.
  • Are a family that will finish a 32 oz jar in under a month on a subscription.
  • Like supporting a small U.S. maker and can wait 1–4 business days for shipping.

Skip it if you:

  • Are buying for a baby under 12 months. Raw honey isn't safe for infants, and the brand says so too.
  • Need a vegan product, despite the badge.
  • Want a lab-verified elderberry amount. Look for a brand that publishes a COA.
  • Want returns if you don't like it. A drugstore brand is easier to return.
  • Live outside the U.S. or receive mail at a PO box.

FAQ

Is The Elderberry Co. syrup safe for babies? No, not for babies under 12 months. The syrup contains raw honey, and the brand itself doesn't recommend it for that age. For older children, ask your pediatrician first.

Does The Elderberry Co. syrup need to be refrigerated? Yes. The jar ships unrefrigerated but should go in the fridge on arrival, opened or not. Use it within about 60 days of the batch date, or freeze it in portions.

Can I return The Elderberry Co. syrup? No. Elderberry Syrup is excluded from the 15-day return policy. Contact the company under its satisfaction guarantee instead.

Is The Elderberry Co. the same as The Elderberry Source? No. The Elderberry Source is a separate Las Vegas company with its own Trustpilot reviews.

Does The Elderberry Co. ship to Canada? No. According to its shipping policy, the company ships only within the United States and doesn't ship to PO boxes.

Does elderberry syrup cure colds or the flu? That hasn't been shown. A few small studies suggest elderberry may ease symptoms, but the NIH calls the evidence limited. Elderberry isn't a substitute for medical care.

Bottom line

The Elderberry Co. is a legitimate small maker with a clean, short ingredient list and a fair price per ounce. Its weak spots are paperwork, not the product: health claims the FDA objected to in 2020, a vague testing badge, a mislabeled "Vegan" badge, and a no-returns syrup. If you go in knowing those, choose a jar size you'll finish within about 60 days, and use the automatic tier discount on bigger orders, it's a reasonable pick for a fresh elderberry syrup.

Shop at The Elderberry Co Here